Viramontes Update: Galil is not Similar to the AR-15? Zion Patriot, November 20, 2026November 20, 2026 A week has passed since Cook County filed its latest effort to have Viramontes v. Cook County dismissed. As of the morning of November 20, the Supreme Court’s public docket records no further filings or orders following the county’s November 13 reply. The justices have yet to resolve the dispute over whether the case should continue. Supreme Court docket The dispute began after Cutberto Viramontes asked to withdraw as a petitioner. Cook County then argued that his departure would leave the Court without a suitable plaintiff to decide the question it agreed to hear: Whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles. Those final words remain central. Christopher Khaya is still a petitioner, and he wants to possess an IMI Galil semiautomatic rifle. Cook County’s ordinance expressly lists the Galil by name among the firearms it bans. The petitioners argue that his existing claim falls within the question presented and keeps the case alive. Granted question · Petitioners’ response Cook County’s reply insists that the lower-court record fails to establish the necessary similarity between the Galil and the AR-15. It also argues that Khaya’s intended use and the Galil’s prevalence present additional problems. But the county’s own earlier description deserves attention. Footnote 3 of the district court’s opinion records that Cook County described Khaya’s rifle as an “Israel Military Industries Galil AR-15 style semiautomatic rifle.” The petitioners initially agreed, then clarified that the Galil was largely based on the AK-47 design. The county now relies on that clarification while leaving its own earlier description unaddressed. District court opinion, reproduced in the cert petition at p. 8a n.3 That clarification establishes a difference in design lineage. It leaves room for the petitioners’ argument that the Galil qualifies as a similar semiautomatic rifle under the question before the Court. Cook County also grouped the ordinance’s named firearms—including the Galil—under the shorthand “AR-15 platform weapons” in its Supreme Court merits brief. Its latest position raises an obvious question about how those earlier descriptions fit its current argument. Cook County’s merits brief, p. 8 The petitioners have supplied additional support. Khaya submitted a declaration stating that he would acquire an AR-15 if he could lawfully possess one in Cook County. FPC and SAF also identified member Ed Smolen, a Cook County resident who keeps his AR-15 out of state and would possess it at home if lawful. Cook County asks the justices to disregard those declarations because they were submitted for the first time at the Supreme Court. It argues that the county lost the opportunity to examine those claims through discovery and that the petitioners failed to follow the procedure for submitting material outside the record. November 11 response and November 13 reply on the Supreme Court docket That procedural objection still leaves Khaya’s original Galil claim. His desired rifle remains expressly banned, and a favorable ruling could provide relief. In my view, that gives the petitioners a substantial argument that a live controversy remains after Viramontes leaves. The justices must decide whether that claim and the existing record are sufficient to proceed under the granted question. Cook County has also asked the Court to dismiss review as improvidently granted, which would allow the justices to conclude that Viramontes is an unsuitable case for deciding the issue. Both sides agree that dismissing Viramontes would leave the consolidated Connecticut case, Grant v. Higgins, before the Court on the same constitutional question. Oral argument remains scheduled for December 2. For now, the county’s request remains pending, and the public docket gives us no answer about how the justices will resolve it. Supreme Court docket 2A News